USB 3.0 today

A couple of years ago I tried USB 3.0 for the first time practically. The same hardware is still in use, but meanwhile you also get fast external 2.5″ harddiscs with a capacity of 2 TB. Also USB sticks for the current standard are quite affordable. A good reason to check the current status.

Good …

The following diagram is the benchmark of a “WD Elements”. This is a 2.5″ harddisc which is produced by Western Digital with a native USB connection, so there is no USB/SATA converter needed in the external case. Therefore the drive is quite compact and also works quite fast:

WD Elements 2 TB

Copying a larger amount of data from an internal drive to the external one (or vice versa) was no problem at all.

USB sticks also became quite fast, at least when reading data as for example a “middle class” model by Verbatim which provides constantly more than 80 MB per second:

Verbatim Store-n-Go 16 GB

… and not so good

While there were no problems using a single harddisc via USB 3 this was not so easy with multiple drives. In particular I connected a „WD Elements“ together with a 1 TB model by Toshiba (also 2.5″) to copy a larger amount of data.

The result was quite disillusioning: After a couple of GB data transferred the Toshiba drive was not accessible any longer and couldn’t be used any longer until the whole system had been restarted (even though I tried to disconnect and connect it again, which did not change anything). It also made no difference if both drives got connected directly to the controller or to the internal hub (which is also powered).

I can’t tell, if this is a problem of the controller, its drivers or the operating system. Maybe a new mainboard with integrated USB 3 controller works better.

At least the combination of the USB stick and harddisc worked trobule-free. During a test with 4 GB of data which were copied from the stick to the harddisc about 70 MB per second were reached and the copy process got finished without errors.

Update: stable operation with new hardware

By the end of 2014 I have replaced my old mainboard with new hardware where the separate USB 3 controller is not needed any more. Here the observed problems did not occur any longer.

Even better: The overall speed also got better, was you can see with in the following diagram.  The USB stick by Verbatim is more than 40% faster:

Verbatim USB stick with a Z97 mainboard

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *